Composite vs pressure-treated decks in Ontario: which should you build?
Pressure-treated costs about half as much to build. Composite costs about half as much to own. The crossover is usually between year 12 and year 18. Here's the honest comparison, with a slider.
The short answer
Build pressure-treated if you're on a budget, plan to sell within ten years, or like the look of stained wood and don't mind a weekend of maintenance every couple of years. Build composite if you'll own the deck long-term, hate staining, or want a deck that looks the same in year 20 as year 1. Cedar is the middle path for people who want real wood without the chemical treatment.
Composite vs pressure-treated, side by side
| Pressure-treated | Composite | |
|---|---|---|
| Installed cost (Kingston, 2026) | $35 to $50 /sq ft | $60 to $90+ /sq ft |
| Maintenance | Clean and stain every 2 to 3 years, about $300 to $600 in materials or $1,000+ hired | Soap and water once or twice a year |
| Lifespan | 15 to 20 years | 25 to 50 years |
| Warranty | None on the boards | 25-year to lifetime manufacturer warranty |
| Winter performance | Checks and splinters over freeze-thaw cycles | Stable; can be slippery with ice like any surface |
| Feel underfoot | Cooler, natural | Warmer in sun, no splinters |
| Fasteners | Screws, visible | Hidden clips, clean surface |
| Resale | Good | Better, buyers recognize the brands |
Cost to own over time: pressure-treated vs composite
A 300 sq ft deck. Slide the years. Includes staining every three years for wood and a board replacement around year 18.
Pressure-treated
…
Build plus staining, plus one board replacement at 18 years.
Composite
…
Build plus an annual wash. Boards carry 25-year or longer manufacturer warranties.
Indicative only: uses 2026 Eastern Ontario per-square-foot ranges and a typical staining cost. Your estimate will be specific.
What we see on Kingston decks after ten years
We rebuild a lot of decks. The pressure-treated ones that were stained on schedule are usually fine at ten years and tired at fifteen. The ones that were never stained have cupped, split boards by year eight. Composite decks from the last decade mostly need nothing but a wash; the frame underneath, which is still pressure-treated wood, is what we check.
That's the part people miss: every composite deck sits on a wood frame. Build the frame right (joist tape, proper ledger flashing, hardware that won't corrode) and the composite boards will outlast it twice over.
Our recommendation by situation
| Your situation | We'd suggest |
|---|---|
| Selling within 5 to 10 years | Pressure-treated, stained |
| Forever home, no interest in maintenance | Capped composite, aluminum railing |
| Cottage or waterfront | Composite (wet environment, hard to maintain remotely) |
| Tight budget, big deck | Pressure-treated, plan to re-deck later |
| Want real wood, will maintain it | Cedar |
Prices on this page come from our deck cost guide. When you're ready, the deck builders page covers how we build, and you can check whether you'll need a permit.
Price both options
Send a few details and we'll call to book a site visit. Photos help, and you can send them once we reply. If you used a tool on this page, your answers come through with the form.
Phone: 343-459-7466
Hours: Mon to Fri, 8 am to 5 pm
Office: 945 Princess Street, Kingston, ON K7L 3N6
Decking material questions
How long does a pressure-treated deck last in Ontario?
Fifteen to twenty years with staining every two to three years. Boards usually go before the frame; many owners re-deck a sound frame around year 15 to 18.
Does composite decking get hot?
Dark composite colours can get noticeably hot in full sun. Lighter colours and newer capped boards run cooler. If the deck faces south with no shade, we'll steer you to a lighter board.
Does composite decking fade or stain?
Modern capped composite (Trex Transcend, TimberTech AZEK and similar) carries 25- to 50-year fade and stain warranties. Older uncapped composite from the 2000s did fade, which is where the reputation comes from.
Can I put composite boards on my existing frame?
Often, yes, if the joists are sound and spaced at 16 inches or less. Composite is heavier and more flexible than wood, so 24-inch joist spacing won't work. We check before quoting.
Is cedar better than pressure-treated?
Cedar looks better and resists rot naturally, but it's softer and costs more. Pressure-treated is stronger and cheaper. Both need staining to keep their colour.